LaxTV Forums | A Forum About The MCLA

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 11:50 am**

2006 WCLL A DIVISION All LEAGUE SELECTIONS

FIRST TEAM

ATTACK
Nick Dean Senior University of California, San Diego
Andres "Cito" Williams Sophomore Sonoma State University
Tim Casey Senior Cal. Poly.- San Luis

MIDFIELD
Brian Johnson Junior Sonoma State University
Michael Farinelli Freshman Chapman University
Peter Hahn Junior University of California, Los Angeles

FACE OFF
Morgan Silldorff Senior University of California, San Diego

LONG STICK MIDFIELDER
Damon Conklin-Morange Senior University of California, Santa Barbara

DEFENSE
Doug Abate Junior University of California, Santa Barbara
Jeff Virden Senior Sonoma State University
Brandon Hays Senior University of California, San Diego
Carson Parmelee Senior University of Arizona

GOAL
Warren Pringle Sophomore Sonoma State University

OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR
Nick Dean University of California San Diego

DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR
Brandon Hays University of California San Diego

A DIVISION COACH OF THE YEAR
Lane Jaffe University of California, Los Angeles

SECOND TEAM

ATTACK
Luke Shaw Sophomore University of California, Santa Barbara
Nick Stratton Junior University of California, Santa Barbara
Chris McCall Junior University of California, San Diego

MIDFIELD
Jaime Dale Senior Sonoma State University
Nick Schooler Senior University of California, Santa Barbara
Harrison Crawford Junior University of Arizona

FACE OFF
Peter Janicki Sophomore St. Mary's

LONG STICK MIDFIELDER
Joel Schmitt-Kallas Senior Chapman University

DEFENSE
Ari Elden Senior Cal. Poly.- San Luis
David Yeaton-Massey Senior University of California
Joe Muratore Junior Arizona State University

GOAL
Blake Wahrlich Senior Chico State University

THIRD TEAM

ATTACK
Seth Kweller Sophomore Cal. Poly.- San Luis
Marcus Wooden Sophomore Chapman University
Will Jun Senior University of California, Los Angeles

MIDFIELD
Mike Clayton Freshman Chapman University
Davis Reilly Junior Cal. Poly.- San Luis
Brian Minkler Sophomore Loyola Marymount University

LONG STICK MIDFIELDER
Eric Simms Junior Chico State University

DEFENSE
Colin Scadden Senior University of California, Los Angeles
Mark Govan Sophomore Cal. Poly.- San Luis
Derek Scadden Junior University of California, Los Angeles

GOAL
Daniel Kirkpatrick Freshman Chapman University

HONORABLE MENTION
Steve Luna Senior University of Arizona
Jeff Pilon Senior Arizona State University
Tyler Westfall Freshman Arizona State University
Scott Brittain Junior Santa Clara University
Tom Hower Sophomore Chico State University
Brian Etheridge Senior University of Arizona
Scott Kelly Junior University of California
Pat Chung Senior University of California, Los Angeles
Paul Komar Senior Arizona State University
Brandon Kim Sophomore San Diego State University
Phillip Donnici Freshman Santa Clara University
Justin Boland Senior San Diego State University

2006 WCLL B DIVISION All LEAGUE SELECTIONS

FIRST TEAM

ATTACK
Dylan Sheridan Senior Claremont Colleges
Danny Barber Sophomore University of San Diego
Josh Agadoni Senior Biola University

MIDFIELD
Devin Muna Junior University of San Diego
Tim Thatcher Junior Claremont Colleges
Bryce Vankooten Junior Biola University

FACE OFF
Joe Bossings Freshman University of California, Santa Cruz

LONG STICK MIDFIELDER
Emery Mitchem Junior Claremont Colleges

DEFENSE
Steven Merrell Senior University of San Diego
Aaron Klett Senior Biola University
Matt Williams Senior Biola University

GOAL
Joe Williams Senior University of San Diego (Edited)

OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR
Dylan Sheridan Claremont Colleges

DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR
Steve Merrell University of San Diego

A DIVISION COACH OF THE YEAR
Pete Ginnegar Claremont Colleges

SECOND TEAM

ATTACK
Ben Tilton Freshman University of San Diego
Chatom Arkin Senior Claremont Colleges
Adrian Charter Sophomore University of California, Santa Cruz
John Hogan Junior University of California, Irvine

MIDFIELD
Tim Mann Senior Biloa University
Eric Arabia Sophomore Biloa University
Tim Pirozzoli Senior University of the Pacific

FACE OFF
Ben Lin Senior University of California, Irvine

DEFENSE
Josh Motlaw Freshman University of California, Santa Cruz
Justin Zelones Senior University of California, Irvine
Russell Masuda Freshman University of the Pacific

GOAL
Alex Price Freshman Claremont Colleges

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 12:13 pm**

Division B First Team
GOAL
Joe Williams Senior Biola University

Joe Williams is goalie for San Diego

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 12:15 pm**

Props to all.

Good job this season!

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 12:55 pm**

Once again very deserving players are overlooked to let more teams be represented on the all league list. It's very disappointing that politics pick the all league players over actual performance and skill.

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 12:58 pm**

I don't follow the league as closely as I used to, but who do you think was omitted westcoastlax?

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 1:28 pm**

sohotrightnow wrote:
2006 WCLL B DIVISION All LEAGUE SELECTIONS

SECOND TEAM

MIDFIELD
Eric Arabia Sophomore Biloa University

[/quote]

Should be UC Santa Cruz

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 1:29 pm**

Well, I don't really want to get into naming all the names because I'm sure that everyone has someone that they feel should have been listed.

But when the second leading scorer for Sonoma (who has been either the first or second leading scorer the last three years, and who gets big points in big games like CSU, UCSB, UCSD, etc.) doesn't even get honorable mention, then you know something is wrong with the system.

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 1:33 pm**

I assume you mean Dan McDonald. Yeah, I was suprprised at that as well. This is no different than any other year though.

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 1:41 pm**

sohotrightnow wrote: This is no different than any other year though.

You've said a mouthful there!

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 2:53 pm**

First, congratulations to the players selected to be all stars this year. Without a doubt 2006 has been a great season. There is more parity in the league now, which I assume equates to making the selection process that much more difficult. I agree that players get "snubbed" every year, but unfortunately that is the nature of this sort of thing, however, I don’t see anything wrong with naming guys that you feel should be considered for the list. Why not just make a list of players you would add to the list, guys you think should be mentioned along with those fortunate enough to have been selected? Especially since there is no honorable mention category in the B division here are my choices:

B Division
Attack:
Sam Mittermiller-Claremont
Third leading most points in the league. He is a great finisher, and tenacious in the ride.
Andrew Grinberg-Occidental
Great playmaker, 4.42 pts/game
Brad Blakely-Pepperdine
Great scorer, he dodges, shoots, and finishes well.

Midfield:
Philip Trapp-Claremont
One of the most fluid players I've seen, and he is only a freshman. He will not be denied next year.
Drew Kaspers-Pepperdine
Plays with strength, and toughness, he is a good dodger, and has a great outside shot.

Face-off:
Matt Moone-Claremont
Best face-off guy in the country.

Defense:
Jason Trapp-Claremont
2005 First Team AA. His game has actually improved tremendously in '06, plus he leads a defense that only gives up only 5g/game.
Jesse Roberts-Occidental
Tough and aggressive, he consistently gives opposing attacks long days.
Mike Hoyt-Pepperdine
Big, physical guy with a great stick and good sense of the game.
Ashton Clarke-Claremont
Consistently dominates opposing attacks with physicality, strength, and great footwork.

Goal:
Jacob Manning-Occidental
Always keeps his team close by making huge saves in big games.

The list could go on…

I have competed with these players and watched them compete against other teams, and feel they earned the right to be mentioned along side with those players listed above. In my opinion there is no harm in acknowledging the guys who "we" think should have been chosen as long as we aren't bashing the guys that were selected. Politics or not, the WCLL has a great deal of talent, and some guys get overlooked, but forums like this one provide us with a platform from which we can speak out and praise those same guys.
Good luck to everyone in the playoffs, and thanks for another great season.

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 3:20 pm**

Before this thread escalates any further, I wanted to clarify the selection process for each Division. They are essentially the same except for the number of players selected for each.

1. At the annual league meeting the number of All League Teams and players is decided. This was unchanged this year.
2. Next the method for determining who would be nominated is discussed. The membership felt that the system used during the last two years was exclusionary, using a committee selected by the league Vice-President, and instead chose to have all coaches nominate their own players for inclusion on the ballot.
3. Each coach in both Divisions was asked to nominate five (5) players from their team whom they felt deserved All League consideration. This was an arbitrary number selected by the league President and Vice President that would allow the coaches enough names for voting consideration but not be too over-bearing in the balloting and voting process. All coaches in the A Division nominated players for their teams. In the B Division, 6 of 10 teams submitted nominations. No requirements were given the coaches in terms of which positionsor how many at each position they could nominate.
4. After receipt of the nominations, a ballot was composed and sent to each coach who nominated players. Those who did not participate in the nomination process were not included and thus players from their respective teams were not considered for selection in 2006. Each coach was asked to select a given number of players for each position and asked to rank them in order from most talented to least talented for each respective position. They were not allowed to vote for players from their own teams. In the A Division, all but one team returned a completed ballot. In the B Division, only 3 of the 6 teams returned ballots.
5. After all ballots were received, the results were tabulated and the respective teams were selected based upon the total number of points each player received in the process.

Overall, fairly apolitical for those conspiracy theorists out there. Is the process flawless- No, but several coaches have already sent in proposals for consideration for next year.

For those players, family members, friends or interested observers, if you feel that a player who was deserving of recognition didn't receive such this season, instead of painting a wide brush of doubt on the process, you should probably start with the players coach to see how far they participated in the selection process that they agreed to in October, 2005.

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 3:32 pm**

Interesting that the Offensive and Defensive players of the year are from UCSD...

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 4:03 pm**

There should be a d-middie classification! Is there a more important position on the field?

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 4:50 pm**

westcoastlax wrote:Well, I don't really want to get into naming all the names because I'm sure that everyone has someone that they feel should have been listed.

But when the second leading scorer for Sonoma (who has been either the first or second leading scorer the last three years, and who gets big points in big games like CSU, UCSB, UCSD, etc.) doesn't even get honorable mention, then you know something is wrong with the system.

sohotrightnow wrote:I assume you mean Dan McDonald. Yeah, I was suprprised at that as well. This is no different than any other year though.

Apparently, McDonald was not nominated. The limit is 5 nominees per team, not enough for a team like Sonoma. The 5 Sonoma St. players nominated were all elected either first or second team All WCLL, same with UCSB. I'm sure that those top players who are juniors will be nominated and elected next year

Posted: **Tue Apr 25, 2006 5:11 pm**

That thought was brought up at the WCLL meeting in October and we all agreed. However, our selections mimic the MDIA All American teams which does not have a d-middie specialist classification as of yet. They are discussing the issue at a national level, so hopefully we will add that specialist category for the 2007 season

LaxTV Forums | A Forum About The MCLA

2006 WCLL All-League Teams are Announced!

2006 WCLL All-League Teams are Announced!

Re: All-League 2006

WCLL ALL LEAGUE SELECTION PROCESS

D-middies

d-middie selection