LaxTV Forums | A Forum About The MCLA

Here is DI (I do not have DII)

Attack

1st
Corey Noonan- FSU
Tim Tyrell- VT
David Drehoff- UCF
2nd
Cabell Cox- UGA
Tom Schauder- VT
Ryan Akin- UF
HM
Matt Jankowski- FSU
Shaun McGahan- UGA
Shawn Nee- NCSU
David Meslar- UT

Midfield

1st
Andrew Spain- VT
Dave Siegel- FSU
Ian Felschow- UGA
2nd
Joe Donovan- UF
Eric Dennis- VT
Jon Yates- FSU
HM
Matt Cleary- UT
Carl Wilson- GT
Chris Park- Vandy
CJ DeMarco- Clemson

Defense

1st
Patrick Okeefe- VT
Drew Clark- UF
Myles Somerville- FSU
2nd
Dave Gouldey- VT
Matt Crabtree- GT
Nick Thomas- UGA
HM
Jack Mata- FSU
CJ Schmidt- UCF
Ryan Starnes- Clemson
Greg Dickinson- NC State

Goalie
1st
Matt Smith- UGA
2nd
Sam Karpowicz- GT
HM
Graham Croisversat- Clemson
Matt Braziti- Wake Forest

Long Stick Midfielder
1st
Daniel Whyte- UF
2nd
David Nussman- NCSU


Face Off Specialist
1st
Sean Simmons- VT
2nd
Chris Wilson- UGA
HM
Alfredo Suarez-Sarmiento Jr

DOUG HORN Award - SELC Offensive Player of the Year- Corey Noonan- Florida State U.
SONNY PIEPER Award - Defensive Player of the Year- Matt Smith- Univ. of Georgia
SELC Coach of the Year- Buff Grubb- Clemson
SELC Rookie of the Year- David Drehoff- Univ of Central Florida
TOM LEWIS Award - SELC Specialty Player of the Year- Chris Sjogren- Florida State U.

i don't know how shaun mcgahan didn't get first team all conference for attack
i'm glad ian felschow got first team but he has played attack all year long and got 1st team midfield...
and how did kevin magyar not get anything

Two FSU related questions:

1. How is Dave Siegel a 1st team middie and not a Top 3 face off middie? No disrespect intended to his all around game but I'd say that his primary contribution is at the X.

2. How is Chris Sjogren the specialty player of the year and not the first or second team all-conference LSM?

Were the coaches trying to spread the wealth? I'm not making a huge criticism, just trying to understand the logic.

is that Noonan's 3rd OMVP award in a row?

Mike Vallone A UCF and Evan Pike A UF are two glaring omissions, no doubt attack was a highly competitive field this year....

without too long of an issue....

Ian was nominated as a Middie by his coach
Chris S is a short stick, not LSM
Attack is ALWAYS the most competitive area

a lot of how this shakes out is based on how the coaches nominate their players and for which poisitions.
There is a committee that then votes on the results.

For FO honorable mention...correct spelling is: Alfredo Suarez-Sarmiento Jr.

Also recall that Evan Pike was named CollegeLAX MCLA Player of the Week for his performance against Georgia and Boston College. (2/15/2008)

Ken Lovic wrote:Chris S is a short stick, not LSM

Yeah, I'm an idiot.

Yes! That is Corey Noonans 3 Offensive Player of the Year award in a row (FR., Soph, JR. years)

Everyone can make arguments for players on their own team of course. For example, in my opinion Andrew Jaffke should be honorable mention minimum for All Conference. Is the biggest thing for goalies their save %? Because if so then that is unfortunate. Yeah its important but, in games where SELC teams beat up on each other (i.e. VT vs. FSU, VT vs. UGA beginning of season) and the score count is high, goalies like Jaffke make huge saves (FSU game) that I wish everyone in the SELC could see. But that's never going to happen because it is nearly impossible.

Ken, any insight on what stats for goalies (i.e. save %?) are looked at in voting?

Just doesn't make sense that the teams who were not as successful could have their goalie make All Conference over top SELC goalies.


Also, did Crawford from Auburn just have a good tournament or has he been this solid all year? Because he too should be an All Conference goalie IMO.

fsucoach wrote:Yes! That is Corey Noonans 3 Offensive Player of the Year award in a row (FR., Soph, JR. years)

Ok, so I agree Corey Noonan is a great player and I'm sure Tim Tyrell was looked at for OMVP. Corey is a great finisher (62 goals reg. season) but only has 17 assists. Matt Janowski of FSU had 41 assists (13 goals), most likely a large % went to Corey. Where as Tyrell has 33 goals and 30 assists on the season. Which leads me to believe Tim is the better all around player. Plus Tim has better stats against the big teams (UGA and FSU) than Noonan has against UGA and VT. Noonan only had 1 goal no assists against UGA and 2 goals no assists against VT. Tyrell had 3 goals 2 assists against UGA and 3 and 3 against FSU. I would just like to know what criteria the votes are based on if possible. Again, not taking away from Noonan, he is a great player; just trying to see what arguments were made against Tyrell.

Either way, i'd love to see this All-Conference team versus the WCLL All-Conference team...that would settle the East vs. West score

CassiusClay wrote:Either way, i'd love to see this All-Conference team versus the WCLL All-Conference team...that would settle the East vs. West score

We'd all love to see that.

vtlax88 wrote:

fsucoach wrote:Yes! That is Corey Noonans 3 Offensive Player of the Year award in a row (FR., Soph, JR. years)

Ok, so I agree Corey Noonan is a great player and I'm sure Tim Tyrell was looked at for OMVP. Corey is a great finisher (62 goals reg. season) but only has 17 assists. Matt Janowski of FSU had 41 assists (13 goals), most likely a large % went to Corey. Where as Tyrell has 33 goals and 30 assists on the season. Which leads me to believe Tim is the better all around player. Plus Tim has better stats against the big teams (UGA and FSU) than Noonan has against UGA and VT. Noonan only had 1 goal no assists against UGA and 2 goals no assists against VT. Tyrell had 3 goals 2 assists against UGA and 3 and 3 against FSU. I would just like to know what criteria the votes are based on if possible. Again, not taking away from Noonan, he is a great player; just trying to see what arguments were made against Tyrell.

If you're going for stats in big games you could put other players in the mix. Shaun Mcgahan scored 3 goals 1 assist in the first game against FSU, 2goals 4assists in first Vatech game, 2 goals and a few assists in the recent fsu game, and 6-7 goals in the championship game.

GeorgiaLacrosse wrote:

vtlax88 wrote:

fsucoach wrote:Yes! That is Corey Noonans 3 Offensive Player of the Year award in a row (FR., Soph, JR. years)

Ok, so I agree Corey Noonan is a great player and I'm sure Tim Tyrell was looked at for OMVP. Corey is a great finisher (62 goals reg. season) but only has 17 assists. Matt Janowski of FSU had 41 assists (13 goals), most likely a large % went to Corey. Where as Tyrell has 33 goals and 30 assists on the season. Which leads me to believe Tim is the better all around player. Plus Tim has better stats against the big teams (UGA and FSU) than Noonan has against UGA and VT. Noonan only had 1 goal no assists against UGA and 2 goals no assists against VT. Tyrell had 3 goals 2 assists against UGA and 3 and 3 against FSU. I would just like to know what criteria the votes are based on if possible. Again, not taking away from Noonan, he is a great player; just trying to see what arguments
were made against Tyrell.

If you're going for stats in big games you could put other players in the mix. Shaun Mcgahan scored 3 goals 1 assist in the first game against FSU, 2goals 4assists in first Vatech game, 2 goals and a few assists in the recent fsu game, and 6-7 goals in the championship game.

Yeah, I agree. But im not just going by big game stats, also overall season stats, that's what Shawn lacks. He's below both Tim and Corey and another VT attackmen Tom Schauder.

i tend to think most of the votes for that sort of award are based on actually seeing the players play...i don't think stats are taken into account as much as everyone thinks.