LaxTV Forums | A Forum About The MCLA

Ok- here it is, the first message board poll following the release of the real poll, as I promised.

#1- Sonoma State - 272 (9)
#2- Colorado State - 262 (1)
#3- UC Santa Barbara - 257 (1)
#4- Michigan - 233
#5- Brigham Young - 228
#6- Florida State - 217
#7- Colorado - 208
#8- Oregon - 205
#9- UC San Diego - 193
#10- Oakland - 159
#11- Virginia Tech - 157
#12- Lindenwood - 149
#13- Arizona - 137
#14- Georgia Tech - 121
#15- Cal Poly - 120
#16- Chapman - 118
#17- Utah - 91
#18- Northeastern - 79
#19- Chico - 77
#20- Michigan State - 66
#21- Boston College - 55
#22- Texas Tech - 51
#23- Minnesota Duluth - 44
#24- University of Texas - 13
#25- Florida - 11


Others receiving votes (in order)- Indiana (10), Arizona State (10), Minnesota (8), Simon Fraser (5), Missouri (4), UCLA (4), Wake Forest (4), Georgia (4), Auburn (2), Pittsburgh (1).

This one was relatively close to the actual poll- only a few changes in position. There were also a good number of spots that were decided by one or two points.

Message Board Poll .... Official USLIA Poll

#1- Sonoma State - 272 (9) .... 1. Sonoma State
#2- Colorado State - 262 (1) .... 2. Colorado State
#3- UC Santa Barbara - 257 (1) .... 3. Univ. of California, Santa Barbara
#4- Michigan - 233 .... 4. Michigan
#5- Brigham Young - 228 .... 5. Brigham Young University
#6- Florida State - 217 .... 6. Florida State
#7- Colorado - 208 .... 7. Oregon
#8- Oregon - 205 .... 8. Colorado
#9- UC San Diego - 193 .... 9. Univ. of California, San Diego
#10- Oakland - 159 .... 10. Virginia Tech
#11- Virginia Tech - 157 .... 11. Oakland University
#12- Lindenwood - 149 .... 12. Lindenwood University
#13- Arizona - 137 .... 13. Georgia Tech
#14- Georgia Tech - 121 .... 14. Chapman University
#15- Cal Poly - 120 .... 15. Arizona
#16- Chapman - 118 .... 16. Northeastern University
#17- Utah - 91 .... 17. Cal Poly SLO
#18- Northeastern - 79 .... 18. Chico State
#19- Chico - 77 .... 19. Utah
#20- Michigan State - 66 .... 20. Boston College
#21- Boston College - 55 .... 21. Minnesota-Duluth
#22- Texas Tech - 51 .... 22. Michigan State
#23- Minnesota Duluth - 44 .... 23. Texas Tech
#24- University of Texas - 13 .... 24. Simon Fraser University
#25- Florida - 11 .... 25. Minnesota

Thanks, benji- it's always good to see that the actual poll really represents what people are generally thinking- and also that those on the message boards (at least some of us) have some idea how things are doing in the country.

I looked through quickly, but I didn't see any teams more than 2 spots off the regular poll- and most of the position changes were by just a few points.

It would be nice if we could get some more poll voters for the MB Poll, since the more we have, the less significance voting anomalies will carry.

PM me if you're interested.

Might not be a bad idea to list who the poll voters are when you release the message board poll.

I a bit surprised to see Texas sneak in there at the bottom of the poll. they are 5-0, but against a teams that have a combined record of 4-14. And if you take UNT out of that the remaining teams are 1-13. They may be a very good team, but at this point I have yet to see anything out of them that would make them a top 25 team. And yes I do realize that 20-25 are basically irrelevant, but just thought is was interesting.

Like I said- the more poll voters, the fewer the oddities- the more input, the closer statistics will get to normalization.

MarkAnderson wrote:I a bit surprised to see Texas sneak in there at the bottom of the poll. they are 5-0, but against a teams that have a combined record of 4-14. And if you take UNT out of that the remaining teams are 1-13. They may be a very good team, but at this point I have yet to see anything out of them that would make them a top 25 team. And yes I do realize that 20-25 are basically irrelevant, but just thought is was interesting.

"Any fool can criticize, condemn and complain......and most fools do." - Dale Carnegie

Don't worry atxlax I'm not criticizing, just thought it was interesting and was trying to start some conversation.

Waterboy,

How many voters does the official poll have and how does that compare to what you are working with? It looked like you were working with around 20 or so which I thought wasn't to bad, but I never knew how many on your list actually ended up being voters. Just curious.

Based on the (9), (1), and (1), I'd say there are 11 voters in the message board poll. I am one of them.

MarkAnderson wrote:Waterboy,
How many voters does the official poll have...

Tim Whitehead wrote:Based on the (9), (1), and (1), I'd say there are 11 voters in the message board poll. I am one of them.

Brilliant Deduction my Dear Watson!
I'm one too!

MarkAnderson wrote:I a bit surprised to see Texas sneak in there at the bottom of the poll. they are 5-0, but against a teams that have a combined record of 4-14. And if you take UNT out of that the remaining teams are 1-13. They may be a very good team, but at this point I have yet to see anything out of them that would make them a top 25 team. And yes I do realize that 20-25 are basically irrelevant, but just thought is was interesting.

I had UT at #25 in my poll, and Tech at #19... just wanted to start a little LSA conversation.

For all of those that voted in the first message board poll, don't forget to send me your second message board poll- preferably by Tuesday night, but Wednesday morning is ok if you're in a time crunch.

This one shouldn't be anywhere near as easy- the season is "gettin good."

This one shouldn't be anywhere near as easy- the season is "gettin good."

Should be an interesting one. I started mine on sunday and I still am not satisfied.... I think i may just finish mine by taking the 15 or so teams who I am not sure where they should be exactly in the poll, closing my eyes and pointing to them on a piece of paper... Good luck to the rest of you in finishing your polls.