Coach Accused of Bullying

Non-lacrosse specific topics.

Coach Accused of Bullying

Postby LaxTV_Admin on Wed Oct 23, 2013 9:31 am

There was a story from ESPN (below) regarding bullying in a Texas Football game. Do you think it was bullying? How do you think lacrosse teams should handle similar situations? There are definitely some lopsided scores in some MCLA games.

Aledo football coach Tim Buchanan was sitting in his Texas office Saturday morning watching game film from a 91-0 victory over Western Hills on Friday night when an email popped up on his computer.

The subject line read "Bullying report."

Buchanan couldn't believe it and thought it was a joke until he read the email and realized a Western Hills parent had filled out the district's online form, accusing the coaching staff of bullying thanks to the lopsided score.

Buchanan spent an hour in the superintendent's office this week and the school is currently investigating, as mandated by the state. The Aledo principal told Buchanan that a written report is expected in the next day or so, something required by state law. Buchanan -- who is in his 21st season as head coach at Aledo and said he has never been accused of bullying -- said he has the support of the Aledo administration.

"[The report filed] compliments our players, saying they showed extremely good sportsmanship," Buchanan said Tuesday morning. "This was not directed at our team, but the coaching staff for not instructing our players to ease up and quit playing hard once the game was in hand."

Western Hills coach John Naylor, whose team dropped to 0-7, didn't have any issues with how Buchanan and his staff handled the game, telling the Fort Worth Star-Telegram that the athletes played hard and didn't "talk at all."

"They're No. 1 for a reason, and I know Coach Buchanan," Naylor told the newspaper. "We're fighting a real uphill battle right now."

Undefeated Aledo, No. 1 in the Associated Press Class 4A state poll (the second-highest classification in the state), is racking up ridiculous yardage and crushing opponents this season. They are averaging just shy of 70 points per game, making some of those games essentially over before halftime.

In fact, at the half Friday, it was 56-0 and Buchanan and his coaching staff spent the intermission trying to figure out how to tap the offensive brakes without embarrassing Western Hills or hindering his own team's progress. Buchanan had one thought: "What are we going to do to not score 100?"

But he was also balancing that with the fact that his team is going to start facing tougher competition in the coming weeks and he wants to be sure his starters are used to playing at least some in the second half.

Buchanan simplified the playbook. He put in the second- and third-team offensive line and got the backups as much time as he could, while still playing a few starters here and there at the beginning of the third quarter. He told his punt returner to fair-catch the ball. All told, his offense had 32 snaps. His starters began coming out in the third quarter, some of them having played just 16 snaps, Buchanan said. The Bearcats rushed for 391 yards with eight touchdowns.

Buchanan said his starting running back touched the ball six times and scored four touchdowns. His backup kept finding holes as well, even without the starting offensive line in the game.

"I can't tell the backups not to play hard," Buchanan said. "They've worked their tails off all week. They've lifted weights in the offseason. I'm not going to tell them not to play."

But he did whatever he could to try to slow down his offense short of taking a knee in the third quarter.

The result was another easy win, but also some time in the principal's office after the report was filed.

Buchanan is now trying to focus on preparing his team for the schedule to stiffen and to be fully ready for the playoffs and a shot at a state title.

Source- ... g-91-0-win
User avatar
Posts: 759
Joined: Mon Oct 09, 2006 8:03 am

Re: Coach Accused of Bullying

Postby slider on Thu Oct 24, 2013 12:23 pm

I think "bullying" is quite a stretch. It's difficult to know what measures a coach is taking to slow down scoring or take the foot off of the gas unless you have some knowledge about the team. If you just see points being put up, but don't realize that it's the fourth string kid scoring, you might think the coach is in the wrong or running up the score. There is only so much a coach can do when the match-up is so completely uneven. Do you tell the fourth string kid in one of the few chances they get to play to not shoot or not to score? If the two teams have absolutely no business on the field together, I think it's reasonable to question why the game is on the schedule in the first place.

As it relates to lacrosse, there has been quite a bit of discussion about this at the MCLA level. Coach Tierney at Denver uses a 19 goal rule to make sure his teams don't embarrass an opponent. The debate about the 19 goal rule is whether it's more embarrassing to an opponent to make no effort to score or shoot than to put up a couple more goals. If you were the losing team, would you prefer to lose 19-2 with the team clearly not trying to score at the end of the game, or to lose 23-2 with some 3rd stringers scoring the last few goals?

I think the coaches of the superior team do bear some responsibility in controlling the scoring, but they can't take all of the blame for a completely lopsided match up.
Posts: 65
Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2005 1:49 pm

Return to Water Cooler

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests